Year-End Review for Coaches: 5 Reflection Questions for an Honest Look Back at 2026
A year-end review for coaches is a written reflection on the quality of your work over the past year. It asks what you achieved with clients, where you grew and what you will do differently in 2027. Taxes, receipts and deadlines belong on a different list.
- Five questions: impact, growth, challenges, letting go and the one investment for 2027.
- Time needed: three 90-minute blocks between late November and mid-December.
- Method: reflection after Schön (1983) and Gibbs' cycle (1988), on paper.
- Result: one page with no more than three decisions, each with a date.
- Taxes: for the self-employed, training is usually a business expense under Art. 27 DBG; check with your fiduciary.
What is a year-end review for coaches, and what does not belong in it?
A year-end review for coaches is a structured look back at your professional practice: at the quality of your sessions, at your development and at the boundaries you set or missed. It answers the question of what kind of coach you were this year. It does not answer the question of how much you earned.
The distinction is important because December is already full for self-employed people. Pillar 3a, open invoices, the VAT threshold and receipts are covered by the year-end checklist for coaches in Switzerland. Utilisation, your effective hourly rate and lead sources belong in the quarterly review for solo coaches. Both are appointments with numbers.
The year-end review is the third appointment, and the one most often skipped. It needs no spreadsheet. It needs quiet, an empty document and the willingness to look honestly. If you only check admin and KPIs, you know at the end of the year exactly what your practice brought in, and very little about how good the work was.
Three features distinguish a real year-end review from a thought experiment on the way home:
- Written: You write the answers down. Thoughts that only circle in your head go round in circles. On paper they become something you can check.
- Evidence-based: You rely on notes, feedback and specific sessions. Your feeling in December is a poor witness for March.
- Decision-oriented: At the end there are decisions for 2027, not resolutions.
Why is reflection more than a nice habit for coaches?
Reflection is core to the craft for coaches because coaching is not a standardised procedure. Every session demands decisions in the moment: ask a follow-up question or stay silent, challenge or hold, stay with the topic or shift the focus. There is no handbook that fits every case.
The organisational researcher Donald Schön described this problem in 1983 in The Reflective Practitioner. He distinguishes two forms. Reflection-in-action is thinking while acting, the brief pause in the middle of a session. Reflection-on-action is thinking afterwards, with distance. The year-end review is reflection-on-action on the largest scale your practice knows.
A study by Frederik Anseel, Filip Lievens and Eveline Schollaert (2009) shows that reflection has a measurable effect. In two experiments with 640 and 488 participants, people who reflected in writing after receiving feedback improved more than those who only received the feedback. Reflection without feedback, on the other hand, brought no improvement.
For you as a coach this means: a year-end review works when it is grounded in real feedback. Client comments, session notes and conversations in supervision are the feedback. Reflection turns them into learning. A review made only of memories stays thin.
When should you do your year-end review, and how long should it take?
The best time for your year-end review is the two or three weeks between late November and mid-December. The year is far enough along to see it as a whole. At the same time you still have room before Christmas, year-end accounts and the January deadlines crowd everything else out.
Plan three blocks of 90 minutes rather than one long afternoon. In our experience, after two hours of self-reflection the answers get shorter and kinder. A split that works well:
- Block 1: Gather material. You go through your calendar, session notes and feedback and mark moments that stand out.
- Block 2: Answer the five questions. You write half a page to a page per question.
- Block 3: Decide. You condense the answers into no more than three decisions for 2027.
A good scaffold for each question is the reflective cycle that the British education researcher Graham Gibbs presented in 1988 in Learning by Doing. It has six steps: description, feelings, evaluation, analysis, conclusion and action plan. The value of the model lies in the order. You first describe what happened, and only then evaluate it.
Gibbs builds on the learning cycle of David Kolb (1984). Kolb describes learning as a loop of concrete experience, reflective observation, abstract conceptualisation and active experimentation. The last step is missing from many year-end reviews. Without it, the insight stays on paper.
Reflection question 1: What did I really achieve with my clients?
The first reflection question examines the impact of your work, and it is harder to answer than it sounds. Many coaches confuse satisfaction with impact. A client who likes coming back is satisfied. Whether they reached their goal is a different question.
So start from specific cases. Pick five client relationships from the year: two that went well, two average ones and one that left you dissatisfied. For each, anonymised and only for yourself, answer:
- Starting point: What did the client come with, and what was their goal in their own words?
- Change: What is different today, and how can you tell?
- Your contribution: Which intervention or stance of yours contributed, and what would have happened without you?
- Ending: Was the engagement deliberately closed, or did it simply fade out?
Research helps you put this in context. The meta-analysis by Theeboom, Beersma and van Vianen (2014) shows that coaching has positive effects on average. Grassmann, Schölmerich and Schermuly (2020) found a clear link between the quality of the working alliance and outcomes. An overview of the evidence is given in the article Does coaching actually work?. For your review this means: for each of the five cases, ask whether real trust developed. The method often explains less than you think.
A second look goes to the relationships that ended without a close. A client who stops booking after the third session is a piece of information. Maybe the goal was reached. Maybe the chemistry was wrong. How to shape endings more deliberately and accompany clients honestly is described in the article on client retention in coaching.
Reflection question 2: Where did I grow as a coach, and which gap remained?
The second reflection question turns your attention to your own development. Growth as a coach rarely shows up as a new certificate. It shows up in situations that would have unsettled you last year and that you now accompany calmly.
A simple exercise for this is the before-and-after list. Write down three skills that noticeably improved in 2026, each with a concrete example. Then write down three skills where you still feel unsure. Possible areas are:
- Conversation skills: tolerating silence, asking precise questions, naming contradictions.
- Process: clarifying the contract, agreeing goals, deliberately closing an engagement.
- Subject matter: expertise in your focus area, such as careers, leadership or health.
- Stance: recognising your own values, keeping distance, discussing your own mistakes openly.
The gap is the more valuable part of the answer. It shows where your next investment lies (more on this in question 5). The list becomes honest when you compare it with feedback. What came up twice in your supervision this year? Which topic kept appearing in client feedback?
Growth also has a direction. Looking back, some coaches notice that their best sessions happened in one particular subject area. That is a hint at a possible specialisation. How to turn this into a clear focus without narrowing yourself is shown in the article finding your coaching niche in Switzerland.
Reflection question 3: Which moments challenged me personally?
The third reflection question is about the difficult moments: cases that kept you up at night, boundaries you drew too late and situations in which you felt unsure or overwhelmed. This question is uncomfortable, and that is exactly why it pays off.
Typical challenges in everyday coaching are:
- Borderline cases: A concern that would have belonged in therapy, and the question of when you should have referred.
- Role conflicts: A sponsor in a company who wanted to know more than you were allowed to share.
- Your own issues: A client whose story came too close to your own.
- Availability: Messages on a Sunday evening that you answered although you did not want to.
Apply Gibbs' cycle especially carefully here. The "feelings" step is the one many people skip. Yet that is often where the explanation lies. If you notice that you constantly wanted to prove yourself with one client, you suddenly understand why those sessions were so draining.
The supervision researchers Peter Hawkins and Nick Smith describe three functions of supervision in coaching: a developmental, a qualitative and a resourcing function. The third creates space to process what you have absorbed from clients. The year-end review performs exactly this function on a small scale.
If your answers to question 3 point to persistent exhaustion, take it seriously. The burnout research of Christina Maslach and colleagues describes exhaustion, detachment and a declining sense of one's own effectiveness as core features. Warning signs and concrete protective measures are in the article burnout prevention for coaches.
Reflection question 4: What will I let go of in 2027, and why did I hold on to it for so long?
The fourth reflection question is a letting-go audit. It asks which offers, habits, client types or commitments you will not take with you into 2027. The second part of the question is the more important one: why did you hold on to it for so long?
The answer is often a well-known thinking error. The psychologists Hal Arkes and Catherine Blumer showed in 1985 that people stick with projects because they have already invested money, time or effort. This sunk cost effect hits coaches especially hard with expensive training, elaborately built programmes and workshops that never really took off. You can read more about this and other thinking errors in the article on cognitive biases in coaching.
A list with three columns helps:
- Keep: What gives you energy and brings your clients something?
- Change: What is good at its core but wrongly shaped, too cheap, too long or too frequent?
- Let go: What would you not start today if you had the choice?
The last column is the test. For every entry you ask: "Would I start this again today?" If the answer is no and the only reason to continue is what you have already invested, the entry belongs on the let-go list. That might be a package format, a network that only costs you evenings, or a habit such as answering emails on the train.
Letting go feels like a loss at first. A few weeks later you usually notice what the space is good for: for the investment from question 5.
Reflection question 5: Which single investment in my development is worth most in 2027?
The fifth reflection question forces you to choose: one single investment in your development as a coach for 2027. One, not five. If you plan three courses, a new certificate and a supervision group, you usually end up doing none of them properly.
The answer follows from question 2. The gap you named there determines the investment. Possible forms are:
- Individual supervision: if you want to process difficult cases better and sharpen your interventions.
- Intervision group: if you miss regular exchange with colleagues and your budget is tight.
- Subject-specific training: if you lack knowledge in your focus area, for example on career questions or team dynamics.
- Federal examination: if you want to secure your qualification formally.
For the last option there is money from the federal government. The State Secretariat for Education, Research and Innovation (SERI, in German SBFI) reimburses 50 percent of the eligible course fees for preparatory courses, up to CHF 9'500 for a federal professional examination and CHF 10'500 for an advanced federal professional examination. The course must be on the official list (Meldeliste) in the year it starts, and you must sit the exam (SBFI). What the different routes cost overall is shown in the article coach training costs in Switzerland.
With supervision, an honest look at the research is worthwhile. A survey of 174 experienced coaches in Australia by Anthony Grant (2012) showed broad support: supervision was seen as an opportunity for reflection, new perspectives and quality assurance, especially in difficult cases. At the same time, 30 percent reported a negative experience, mostly with peer groups or inexperienced supervisors. A systematic literature review by Tatiana Bachkirova and colleagues (2020) also describes coaching supervision as a young field of knowledge.
The conclusion: choosing the person is more important than the format. How supervision, intervision and peer coaching differ and how to find a suitable form is explained in the article supervision and intervision in coaching.
Can I deduct training costs as a business expense as a self-employed coach?
As a self-employed coach you can generally deduct professionally oriented training costs as a business-justified expense. The legal basis is Art. 27 para. 1 of the Federal Act on Direct Federal Taxation (DBG). In its Circular No. 42 of 30 November 2017, the Swiss Federal Tax Administration (ESTV) states that self-employed people can deduct their own education and training costs in the year they are incurred under Art. 27 para. 1 DBG, provided they are business-justified.
In addition there is the general deduction for professionally oriented education and training under Art. 33 para. 1 let. j DBG. It applies to all individuals and is capped. According to the circular, self-employed people can also claim additional costs through this deduction. The cap is adjusted periodically for inflation. You can find the current value on the ESTV page listing the direct federal tax circulars and in the documents of your canton, which sets its own limits.
Two clarifications from the circular are interesting for coaches:
- Hobbies do not count: Courses that are mainly leisure-oriented are not considered professionally oriented.
- Counselling is not training: For the Art. 33 deduction, coaching, training and career counselling are generally not treated as further education, because they solve a specific problem rather than pass on knowledge.
For your own supervision this means: whether it counts as a business expense depends on the professional purpose. The label on the invoice does not decide it. Record the link to your work, keep the invoices and clarify the classification with your fiduciary. An overview of all typical deductions is given in the article taxes for coaches in Switzerland.
How did Franziska Bauer build her own year-end review?
Franziska Bauer has been working as a career coach and supervisor in Bern for six years. In the autumn of her second year of self-employment, she noticed that she was only "getting through" her sessions. She slept badly, cancelled on friends and caught herself looking at the clock during sessions. The turning point came from a single conversation in supervision.
Since then she has done a year-end review every year in early December, spread over three mornings. It always starts with the same question:
"I ask myself: what would I advise my client if they described to me how I worked this year? The answer is almost always clearer than anything I would tell myself. With clients I see immediately when someone is carrying too much. With myself I need this small detour."
The question works because it changes perspective. As a coach you are practised at recognising patterns in others. With yourself, the distance is missing. The anchor question lends you that distance.
Franziska uses the answer as a touchstone for her five questions. She writes it at the top of the page, answers the five questions and finally checks whether her decisions fit the advice she would have given a client. If a decision does not fit, she crosses it out.
How do you document the results of your year-end review?
The best way to document the results of your year-end review is on a single page that you take out again in January and at every quarterly review. Long reflective texts are valuable while you write them. As a working document for the new year they are of little use.
A proven structure for the one-page year-end review:
- Anchor question: your answer in two to three sentences.
- Impact: the one client story that told you the most about your work, anonymised.
- Growth: three strengths that have grown, and the one gap that remains.
- Challenge: the most difficult moment and what you take away from it.
- Letting go: what you will no longer take with you, with a date.
- Investment: the one development investment for 2027, with budget and starting month.
- Decisions: no more than three, each as a concrete sentence.
Write the longer texts anyway. The social psychologist James Pennebaker showed in several studies that structured writing about stressful experiences can help people process them. The long version is your thinking space, the one page your work plan.
One point about protecting your clients: even private reflection notes often contain details from which people can be identified. Use initials instead of names and store the documents the way you store your session notes. The Swiss Federal Act on Data Protection (FADP) also applies to your records as a self-employed person.
How do you turn your year-end review into concrete decisions for 2027?
Your year-end review turns into decisions when you translate each insight into a plan with a situation and an action. A sentence like "In 2027 I will pay more attention to my boundaries" is a resolution. A sentence like "If a client writes after 7 pm, I reply the next morning at 8 am" is a decision.
The psychologist Peter Gollwitzer calls such plans implementation intentions, that is, if-then plans. In his 1999 review he describes how people put goals into practice much more often with such plans than with general intentions. The reason: the plan links a specific situation with an action decided in advance, so you no longer have to decide anew in the moment. How goal setting in coaching works psychologically is described in the article goal setting in coaching.
This is how you translate the five questions into decisions:
- From question 1: a change in your process, for example a fixed closing conversation after every engagement.
- From questions 2 and 5: the development investment with starting month and budget.
- From question 3: a boundary as an if-then plan.
- From question 4: an offer or habit that you end with an end date.
Limit yourself to three decisions. Put each in your calendar with a date on which you check whether you have implemented it. The first quarterly review in March works well for this. There, alongside the numbers, you will also see whether you have become the coach you wanted to become.
How does bondigoo support you with your annual reflection?
bondigoo helps you mainly with the first block of the year-end review, gathering material. In the integrated client CRM, sessions and your private notes appear in a shared timeline for each client. Your notes are visible only to you.
Three features are particularly useful for reflection:
- Note types: You classify notes, for example as a milestone, observation or risk. In December you filter for milestones and see the turning points of every client relationship.
- Pinned notes: What mattered to you during the year stays at the top and does not get lost in the history.
- Goals per client relationship: You record the starting point and goals and can compare them with the outcome in hindsight.
On top of that come the ratings and comments that clients leave after sessions. They are part of the feedback that, according to Anseel and colleagues, makes your reflection effective in the first place. A rating does not replace your own judgement, but it stops you from judging the year from memory alone.
The reflection itself remains your work. No tool will tell you what you want to let go of. If you want to keep your client relationships and notes in one place from 2027, you can sign up on bondigoo and build your coach profile.
Sources
- Schön, D. A. (1983). The Reflective Practitioner: How Professionals Think in Action. Basic Books.
- Gibbs, G. (1988). Learning by Doing: A Guide to Teaching and Learning Methods. Further Education Unit, Oxford Polytechnic.
- Kolb, D. A. (1984). Experiential Learning: Experience as the Source of Learning and Development. Prentice-Hall.
- Anseel, F., Lievens, F. & Schollaert, E. (2009). Reflection as a strategy to enhance task performance after feedback. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 110(1), 23-35. IDEAS/RePEc.
- Hawkins, P. & Smith, N. (2013). Coaching, Mentoring and Organizational Consultancy: Supervision, Skills and Development (2nd ed.). Open University Press.
- Grant, A. M. (2012). Australian coaches' views on coaching supervision: A study with implications for Australian coach education, training and practice. International Journal of Evidence Based Coaching and Mentoring, 10(2), 17-33. DOAJ.
- Bachkirova, T., Jackson, P., Hennig, C. & Moral, M. (2020). Supervision in coaching: Systematic literature review. Oxford Brookes RADAR.
- Theeboom, T., Beersma, B. & van Vianen, A. E. M. (2014). Does coaching work? A meta-analysis on the effects of coaching on individual level outcomes in an organizational context. The Journal of Positive Psychology, 9(1), 1-18.
- Grassmann, C., Schölmerich, F. & Schermuly, C. C. (2020). The relationship between working alliance and client outcomes in coaching: A meta-analysis. Human Relations, 73(1), 35-58.
- Maslach, C., Schaufeli, W. B. & Leiter, M. P. (2001). Job burnout. Annual Review of Psychology, 52, 397-422.
- Arkes, H. R. & Blumer, C. (1985). The psychology of sunk cost. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 35(1), 124-140.
- Gollwitzer, P. M. (1999). Implementation intentions: Strong effects of simple plans. American Psychologist, 54(7), 493-503.
- Pennebaker, J. W. (1997). Writing about emotional experiences as a therapeutic process. Psychological Science, 8(3), 162-166.
- Federal Act on Direct Federal Taxation (DBG), SR 642.11, Art. 27 and Art. 33. Fedlex.
- Swiss Federal Tax Administration (ESTV). Circular No. 42: Tax treatment of professionally oriented education and training costs (30 November 2017). ESTV.
- State Secretariat for Education, Research and Innovation (SBFI). FAQ on federal contributions for federal examinations: graduates.